---

UPDATE: 03/17/26: Since this original post on January 10, there have been numerous reports on social media that the demolition of the Mutineer Restaurant has occurred, making way for a new retail/ residential development.

---

---

The journey to Key West, Florida, bypasses urban Miami and Homestead via a busy, multi-lane turnpike, then continues for about 130 miles along the beautiful—but mostly two-lane—Overseas Highway. The drive is well worth the effort, though it can be a bit arduous.

A short stretch of road between the southern end of the Florida Turnpike and the bridge to Key Largo marks the beginning of the Overseas Highway to Key West. This area features a mix of gas stations, eateries, and retail shops.

For over 20 years, the pirate-themed Mutineer Restaurant welcomed travelers on the left side of Highway 1 heading south. Owned by Allan Bennett, the ship-motif restaurant and lounge became a last stop for pilgrims bound for the Keys and a favorite local watering hole. The Wharf Lounge inside offered live bands and affordable drinks. The Mutineer earned a reputation for its lively, laid-back atmosphere.

A combination of an aging building, declining sales, negative reviews, and failing health inspections led to the Mutineer’s closure in 2017. The land was set to host a new grocery store, but those plans fell through. Recently, Florida City approved a mixed-use development of retail and townhomes for the site.

The Mutineer still stands, awaiting demolition as it slowly decays in the relentless South Florida heat and humidity. A symbol of 1970s and 1980s Florida, it is gradually fading into history.

January 10, 2026

Thanks for visiting!

Click here to see all my Out-Of-Business/ Abandoned Places posts.

Click here to see a full-size, no watermark, images at www.ImagesByBill.us

(comments are welcome)

---

I appreciate your support and hope you enjoy my posts! Together, we can keep the creativity flowing and deliver even more engaging content. Thank you for being part of this journey!

Any donations would be greatly appreciated.